About Don Carmelo's Pizzeria

Our History

When the Magistro Family immigrated from Sicily to America in the late 50s, they brought their family recipes for authentic Italian dishes to a nation that knew hamburgers and fried chicken and pot roast and nothing about stromboli and calzones.

Since 1959, they have operated pizzerias in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Florida and California before settling in Nebraska in 1980.

Today, in an environment where the emphasis is on mass-produced commercialized food, and where “fast food” and “me-too products” rule by massive advertising and marketing gimmicks, “good food” is usually hard to find.

At Don Carmelo’s Pizzeria, you can be assured of our continued personal commitment to use high quality ingredients in the preparation of our menu and to serve great tasting food prepared in the traditional Italian manner, with quick and courteous service, and where the customer satisfaction is always guaranteed! This is evident from the fact that we have been delighting people with our amazing food for over 64 years.

Check out our gallery of images below:

Our Party Room

Our Party Room can be reserved for your special occasion. Whether you are celebrating a special day like a wedding prenuptial dinner, family gathering, bachelor or bachelorette party, business meetings or other event, Don Carmelo’s Pizzeria Party Room is designed to make your special day, a hit!

We host sport banquets, rehearsal dinners, birthday and anniversary celebrations and business meetings. Groups from 10-90 find the Party Room at our Elkhorn location a perfect spot to hold your special event. Let our crew handle everything from the preparation to the clean-up.

Order right off our delicious menu or for larger groups, let Chef Robert whip up a Sicilian Masterpiece ready to feed an army of hungry party-goers.

Enjoy the ambiance of our World Famous Mural Room with scenes from the Magistro Family home in Italy.

Contact Amy at (402) 289-9800 or drop us an email to book your next event with us

Does your event need the food, but not the location?

Our Catering Services

Make your next sales meeting a success! Don Carmelo’s Pizzeria serves the Greater Omaha area and can handle your special catering needs. Choose something from our menu or let Chef Robert whip up something special like his famous baked red or white pasta treat.

For your next party, event or celebration don’t forget Don Carmelo’s Pizzeria.

Of course, you can order pizza, but we’re more than that. Our party stromboli makes a nice centerpiece on any table. Don’t forget a mixed lettuce salad and an assortment of brownies or gelato! Have a last minute catering need? Give us a   call.  We’re great in a pinch. We’ll even bring the plates, cups, plasticware, and soft drinks.

Call Robert or Amy at (402) 289-9800 or  email us the next time you want to impress.